Hi folks! I’m rerunning some of my old posts to revisit my old work and to help keep this blog more consistently active.
Link to old post: https://elliottdunstan.com/2018/06/26/review-consumed-by-david-cronenberg/
Full text:
David Cronenberg’s debut novel Consumed is… weird. Not bad-weird and not quite good-weird either; like his famous movies, Consumed is a trip through a rabbit-hole of paranoia, conflicting truths, and a conspiracy theory that by the end of things seems to involve North Korea and spell doom for the two main journalists.
I’ll be honest. Consumed, as a novel trying to tell a story, isn’t great. It’s a lot of various horrifying ideas all pulled together and not quite connecting, written in absolutely gorgeous and chilling prose – but it ends just before the conclusion that readers have been working towards, and the conspiracy theory it orients itself around gets to the point of disbelief. That being said, the ideas and images in the book are powerful. Cronenberg connects seemingly disparate images into a set of metaphors, and pulls you down into the depravity involved. It’d be a much better book if it had an ending, but I suppose that’s where imagination comes in.
Ultimately, Consumed functions more as a series of vignettes and thought streams than a cohesive novel. If that’s the kind of thing that interests you, go for it! But don’t expect a narrative that entirely makes sense.
However, I wouldn’t be doing my job as a reviewer if I didn’t make sure to put a MASSIVE content warning on this book. I mean, it’s Cronenberg, so one can assume a certain level of body horror anyway, but it’s about cannibalism, literally (and figuratively) consuming a woman’s body, and a weirdly high amount of sex scenes. There are also some slightly twitchy moments in regards to the Tokyo setting and Japanese culture in general.
I wrote this back in 2018, and while this seems like more or less a fair review, it’s interesting seeing how I’ve changed. I don’t think I would have the patience for this book now, certainly if my memories of it are accurate; and I remember the Japanese stuff being more than a “bit twitchy”, but of course this was also my very first WordPress-based review. (Maybe my first public one at all?) I also am a little clearer about spoiler vs non-spoiler reviews now; this really doesn’t spoil anything about Consumed, but I was obviously doing a lot of work to try say what I wanted without actually… saying much at all.
Want to support me? Check out my SubscribeStar! You’ll get my main posts (four a month) 48 hours early, and one exclusive post a month.
Elliott Dunstan 